Further Reflections on Kitzmiller
What is really bad about the Kitzmiller opinion is that Judge Jones said so much. What is really great about the opinion is that Judge Jones said so much.
The opinion is 139 pages that do not just decide the case at hand, but try to deal a death blow to intelligent design generally. 139 pages leaves a lot of room for judicial mistakes, logical mistakes, historical mistakes and other kinds of mistakes. And Judge Jones used his 139 pages to make a lot of mistakes.
But that is what bloggers are for, right?